News, data and conversation
about schools in New York City.
WNYC’s participation is supported by

High Teacher Turnover at a Success Network School

Staff at Harlem Success Academy 3 greet students during morning drop-off.Ari Mintz for The New York TimesStaff members at Harlem Success Academy 3 greeting students during morning drop-off.
Question What are your thoughts on teacher turnover?
Respond

Oct. 19, 2011, 1:28 p.m.

More than a third of the staff members at a Harlem charter school run by the Success Charter Network have left the school within the last several months, challenging an organization that prides itself on the training and support it offers its teachers.

The unusually high turnover at Harlem Success Academy 3 and the network-wide issue of teachers quitting mid-year led the founder and chief executive of the Success Charter Network, Eva S. Moskowitz, to express concern in an October newsletter.

“This is not a ‘gig’ ” she wrote, informing staff members that by breaking their commitment to the schools and families midyear, they were acting unethically.

At Harlem Success Academy 3, 22 of the school’s 59 administrators, teachers and classroom aides left between the end of the last school year and the beginning of this one, according to the school’s records. Some took jobs at other schools, some moved to new cities and some said they quit out of frustration with the school’s tightly regulated environment.

The loss of more than 30 percent of its teachers distinguishes the school within its network of six other schools, where turnover is less common. At Harlem Success Academy 1 and Harlem Success Academy 2, the attrition rates were about 19 percent between June and this month. And at the network’s two Bronx schools, few faculty members left.

Charter schools have generally experienced relatively high teacher turnover. From 2008 to 2010, charter schools’ average attrition rate was 25 percent and district schools’ was 14 percent, according to state data.

Among those who left Harlem Success Academy 3 was the school’s principal, Emily Rodriguez, and its assistant principal. Ms. Rodriguez is now the director of literacy for Explore Schools, a growing network that now has three charter schools in Brooklyn. Seven Harlem Success Academy 3 teachers have also departed for jobs at Explore Schools between June and this school year.

Ms. Moskowitz said the teachers left in part because Ms. Rodriguez was a popular principal, and in interviews, several teachers supported the explanation. The teachers said Ms. Rodriguez’s departure, which followed a maternity leave, had prompted some teachers to look for work elsewhere.

Ms. Moskowitz said some staff had also quit to pursue graduate school or move outside the city.

“It’s hard for kids and families when you have an exodus,” she said. “My focus when this happened was really to make sure that it’s a great school and the kids had teachers when they started.”

She said that the school is doing well under its new principal, Richard Seigler, a former dean of students and teacher at Harlem Success Academy 4. At 25, Mr. Seigler is one of the city’s youngest principals.

Few of the teachers who left Harlem Success Academy 3 would speak about why they quit, and those who did refused to be named, citing fear of retribution or concern that they could lose their new teaching positions.

Morty Ballen, the founder and chief executive of Explore Schools, said he had not intentionally poached Success Academy’s teachers.

One former Harlem Success Academy 3 teacher who quit at the end of last school year said she had left because she felt “micromanaged.”

“You couldn’t teach in the way you wanted to teach,” she said. “If your kids weren’t sitting perfectly, looking straight at the teacher, not saying a single word, then you weren’t doing your job.”

Monica DeFabio, a third-grade teacher who is in her second year at Harlem Success Academy 3, said she did not know why many of her former colleagues left. “I really can’t say anything has suffered,” she said. “Richard’s come in, and he’s hit the ground running.”

Ms. Moskowitz said she was aware that some teachers had left because they wanted to work in a different type of school, yet she stressed that with 57,000 applications for 256 jobs this year, her schools were in demand.

“We believe in teacher choice just like we believe in parent choice,” she said. “Some teachers want a single-sex school, or a progressive model, or a traditional model of education.”

In her October newsletter, Ms. Moskowitz said that the network was working hard to retain its teachers, but had struggled this year with the issue of teachers quitting after school was already in session.

“We have had a number of teachers quit the night before schools starts — after midnight!” she wrote. “We have had teachers quit two weeks into school. A quick e-mail reads ‘sorry for the inconvenience. …’ ”

It is not merely a logistical predicament, the message continued. “Breaking your commitment in the middle of the year is a big deal and frankly, unethical,” Ms. Moskowitz wrote.

Available data does not indicate how many of the network’s teachers left in the middle of this or last school year. In an interview, a former Harlem Success Academy 1 teacher who quit several months into last school year said it was a decision she made only after realizing there was an impassable gulf between how she wanted to run her classroom and the teaching and discipline methods her supervisor insisted on.

By the time Thanksgiving rolled around and she decided to leave, several other Harlem Success Academy 1 teachers had already quit, she said.

“I got the impression very early on that there were a lot of people wanting my job and that if I left, they would find someone else to do it,” she said.

This fall, the Success Academy Network opened two new schools, one in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn, and the other on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. Next year, Ms. Moskowitz plans to open three new schools in the Brooklyn neighborhoods of Cobble Hill, Bedford-Stuyvesant and Williamsburg.

Anna M. Phillips is a member of the SchoolBook staff. Follow her on Twitter @annamphillips.

Picture?type=square
Yvette Masullo April 11, 2012, 11:00 PM

I teach both math (algebra & geometry) and biology and am certified for both. I teach at a private, struggling boys Christian high school in lower manhattan. I've entertained thoughts of trying to move to a place such as a charter school but having heard that my transition could put my career at risk makes it very unlikely that I'd ever pursue the change. Even if the salary is significantly greater, why change and risk not having a job the following year. This system really hurts itself. Many long term, excellent teachers wouldn't mind a change, but not if tenure is lost and jobs are always at risk. I would love to teach and impact public school students but it is a frightening concept. (I've been in Who's Who of American HS teachers more than once...but this would mean nothing in terms of going to a new school and being retained.).

Add Reply
Picture?type=square
Dominick Speziale October 20, 2011, 10:32 PM

The high turnover rate is neither new or a surprise. New Teachers were denied tenure in a wholesale fashion after working 3 and even 4 years and feel no loyalty to the system. The turnover of new teachers has always been high but for those that stuck it out they could feel a certain satisfaction in earning tenure. That no longer appears to be an attainable path, so they are walking . This generation is infinitely mobile and demands instant gratification which is just not realistic in todays climate.

Add Reply
Picture?type=square
Kimberly Smart August 16, 2012, 11:23 PM

Definitely not a surprise.

Add Reply
Add a Response
SchoolBook Bulletin Board
Welcome to SchoolBook

Schoolbook is a site dedicated to news, data and conversation about schools in New York City.

Have a News Tip?

Tell us what’s going on in your school. You can e-mail us with your tips or documents, or call 646-801-9698 and leave a voice message.

Contribute to Current & Future News Coverage

Join the Public Insight Network and help our journalists cover education in the city. Your stories and insights can help us create relevant and distinctive reporting. Join more than 100,000 people and become a trusted source.